Yield and high quality: is much less actually extra?

Burgundy’s vignerons have been blessed with amount in 2023, however – on the subject of making high quality wine – how a lot is an excessive amount of? We spoke to a number of prime producers to seek out out if low yields actually do imply higher high quality

Previous, low-yielding vines. I’ve written that phrase extra occasions than I’d prefer to confess. However how a lot does it actually imply on the subject of the standard of the wine in your glass?

Within the Previous World, appellation guidelines will restrict yields, with the yield usually lowering as you progress up the appellation system (see under a desk detailing the utmost yields for Burgundy, for instance). In fact, this means a relationship between yield and high quality, implying much less is best – and there’s no doubt that extreme yields don’t produce high quality wine.

However how low is simply too low? There’s a style for prizing vines that hardly handle to ripen a bunch or two, however do they actually make higher wine than these producing a good crop? Past our obsession with rarity, what are the results of much less fruit per vine – and due to this fact, what does extra entail?

Above: harvest underway at Belargus in Anjou, captured by Jean-Yves Bardin. Prime of web page: harvest at Baettig.

A observe on measuring yield

Earlier than we get into the weeds of the matter, let’s tackle how we discuss yield. Within the Previous World, the most typical measurement of yield is hectolitres per hectare (hl/ha), measuring the amount of juice or wine per hectare of winery space. In Champagne the usual measure is kilos per hectare and in Italy you might even see reference to quintales per hectare (qt/ha or q/ha, with one quintal translating to 100kg), whereas within the US, producers are extra possible to make use of tons per acre.

We’ll dive additional into the various variables right here, but it surely’s price highlighting that vine density isn’t taken under consideration by any of those measurements. Though the next variety of vines per hectare will usually imply the next yield throughout the winery, the elevated competitors can even possible scale back the yield per vine.

The long-lasting Ch. Margaux

Yields: how low is simply too low?

Mike Dunn (Dunn Vineyards) usually has low yields, however that’s not essentially about focus, he explains: it’s merely about how a lot they’ll ripen earlier than winter hits. Up on Napa’s Howell Mountain, their poor soils and farming (avoiding irrigation and fertilisation the place they’ll) naturally produce decrease yields. He just lately modified a few of their Cabernet Sauvignon to cane (somewhat than cordon) pruning and, though they’re getting extra fruit off the identical vines, there’s been no loss in high quality.

Massonnat explains how when you farm to supply yields which can be overly low, you possibly can find yourself with fruit that has excessive technical, or sugar, maturity, however isn’t but phenolically ripe – resulting in unbalanced wines. Smith echoes this, speaking particularly about Beckstoffer Dr Crane, considered one of Napa’s legendary vineyards, which he finds likes to supply extra – round 5 tons an acre (versus 4 in many of the vineyards he works with). He sees producers cropping to only three tons per acre there, and in heat vintages the fruit ripens too rapidly for the phenolics to catch up.

Matthew Fioretti of Cerbaiona

Equally, throughout the Durantou household’s estates on the Proper Financial institution, together with Ch. l’Eglise-Clinet, Noëmie Durantou Reilhac targets a yield of circa 42hl/ha. “The vine needs to supply fruit,” she says, “so if the yield is actually, actually low, one thing went flawed.” For her, it’s the steadiness that issues most. With very excessive yields, the ensuing wines will lack focus (“You can’t make in tanks what nature hasn’t performed earlier than,” she says), however equally if the berries are so small that there’s barely any juice, you’ll have little however tannins left to work with. And, whereas hail or frost will scale back your yield, they gained’t end in larger focus.

“I feel it simply comes all the way down to stress,” Dunn tells me. And that’s a standard thread for a number of producers, arguing that vines have to wrestle to supply high quality. As Sébastien le Golvet – of Champagne Henri Giraud, who works with the poor soils of Aÿ – says, “genii are born of struggling”. Struggling doesn’t at all times imply decrease yields, nevertheless: arguably, Dunn says, in high-vigour websites, protecting increased yields will assist enhance stress, pushing the vine to work tougher – and due to this fact produce increased high quality.

Muscat being harvested at Klein Constantia

Components impacting yield

Whereas it’s unattainable for us to handle each issue that influences yield, it’s price – comparatively briefly – highlighting a number of extra influences past web site (with poorer or richer soils), selection and classic:

Vine materials/rootstock: The fabric utilized in a winery is integral (as with Quinta do Noval’s Nacional winery, see under). Mike Dunn, for instance, talked about how considered one of his older vineyards was planted on St George rootstock, identified for shatter and due to this fact limiting yields even additional. Jean-Marie Fourrier (Domaine Fourrier) argues that using chosen clones, somewhat than massal choice, has resulted in increased yields and the necessity to inexperienced harvest, one thing that he by no means does – aided additional by the age of his vines (see under for extra on this).

Vine age: There’s little question that the factor of vine age is conflated with yields and high quality, with older vines typically producing higher fruit – however much less of it. As Mike Dunn informed me, the wines from his oldest vines are “extra intriguing”, however sooner or later economics comes into play, and the extent of manufacturing is financially unsustainable. It’s one other non-linear relationship, nevertheless, as Durantou Reilhac explains: “Some 70-year-old grandmas can run and dance, and others are weaker.” Though most aged vines will produce much less fruit, she finds it’s removed from uniform in her vineyards – and generally there can be younger vines that produce much less.

The solar shining at Montlandrie within the Castillon, one of many Durantou estates

Virus and millerandage: Virused vines will produce decrease yields, and as with previous vines, will attain some extent the place they’re unsustainable. Whereas on the floor virus is detrimental, sure producers do worth the discount in yield or slower ripening that could be a results of illness – South Africa’s Hamilton Russell being one (with leafroll virus). Quinta do Noval persists with its own-rooted Nacional winery, affected by phylloxera, with the vines slowly dying and yielding tiny volumes, to supply a very particular and uncommon Classic Port. Equally, millerandage is a situation mostly a consequence of poor climate at fruit-set, producing grape clusters with erratically sized grapes, combining bigger and smaller (or shot) berries – generally referenced as hen-and-chick. Whereas this reduces yield, the phenomenon is usually valued for giving elevated focus to wine. Certainly, some specific clones – such because the Mendoza, Wente or Gingin clones of Chardonnay – are valued for his or her bunches with hen-and-chicks, and Bret Brothers, for instance, even makes a particular Cuvée Millerandée – with millerandée Chardonnay – from Les Quarts (a Pouilly-Vinzelles web site just lately awarded Premier Cru standing).

Cowl crops: At Henri Giraud, Sébastien le Golvet feels that cowl crops are important to the standard of their fruit – and the yield. Sewn simply earlier than harvest, the quilt crops present competitors up till flowering after they roll the grass combine, making a mattress that holds water and affords nitrogen to the soils, appearing as a pure fertiliser – in a manner each moderating then fuelling the vines’ development. That is one trace on the extent to which the kind of soils and degree of natural matter, to not point out water availability, dictated by web site and the farming strategies, are all key.

The earlier classic: There are two theories at play right here. Firstly, situations throughout what is called the initiation part of the vine cycle, which takes place alongside flowering, will dictate the yield of the next classic. In 2023 in Burgundy for instance, one of many components in yield was that the spring of 2022 provided excellent situations, laying the groundwork for 2023’s plentiful crop. As Sébastien le Golvet additionally defined, nevertheless, a big crop in a single classic can tire the vines, that means they’ve much less to present the next 12 months.

Dunn Vineyards on Napa’s Howell Mountain

How wine producers handle yield

The vine naturally needs to breed, to develop, ripen fruit and unfold its seeds. Vignerons are tasked with taming the plant to focus its energies to develop fruit of focus and complexity that may make high quality wine. That is performed in some ways, a few of which embody:

De-budding or suckering: In spring, producers will de-bud or sucker the vines, eradicating lateral shoots and offering additional management of the potential yield, in addition to the spacing and place of the crop. In 2023 in Burgundy, many producers emphasised how essential this was. Hugues Pavelot described it as “drastic”, whereas Philippe Jouan handed by his vines twice. At Bouchard, Frédéric Weber defined how a number of the buds produced two or three bunches in 2023 (somewhat than the conventional one), that means that even with in depth de-budding yields have been very excessive.

Inexperienced harvesting: Inexperienced-harvesting is essentially the most mentioned technique of yield management, and one which divides producers. We spoke to a number of Burgundian vignerons who keep away from it (Dominique Lafon, Jacques Devauges at Domaine des Lambrays, Philippe Jouan and Jean-Marie Fourrier, to call a number of) – a few of whom felt that that they had no selection however to make use of the strategy in 2023, regardless of their finest efforts. The rationale in opposition to green-harvesting is that the vine will attempt to compensate, and that it may be averted with managing the winery in different methods. That mentioned, there are various top-tier producers that green-harvest, and really feel it’s key to the standard they produce (Ch. Margaux, Eglise-Clinet, Georges Noëllat and Olivier Bernstein, to call a number of). And it’s not a call that any take calmly, nicely conscious that they’re actually throwing away potential revenue.

At Cerbaiona, Fioretti compares the vines to runners or cyclists – needing to hold as little weight as attainable to recover from the end line. With Sangiovese, he finds it’s unavoidable, particularly with the presence of “wings” or “shoulders” (smaller separate clusters that sit on the shoulder of the primary bunch).

The timing is vital, and lots of producers emphasise the significance of green-harvesting early within the season. For Noëmie Durantou Reilhac, she goals to have this performed previous to véraison to keep away from twisting the stems (which might impression sap stream) and damaging the skins of the remaining bunches. She’ll do a closing go by her vineyards simply earlier than harvest, however it is a technique of sorting somewhat than impacting the ripeness of the grapes on the vine. “There’s a sure level the place you possibly can scale back fruit, say a month away from choosing, but it surely gained’t do something,” says Myriad’s Mike Smith. Like many producers, he favours green-harvesting mid-véraison to drop something that’s behind, serving to even the ripeness of the crop – as Bascaules does at Ch. Margaux. In 2023, a number of Burgundy producers highlighted having to do a number of passes to scale back the crop – doing what was generally known as a “pink” or “blue” harvest on prime of a inexperienced harvest.

Sébastien le Golvet of Champagne Henri Giraud

Cover administration: A vine’s leaves are its engine – accountable for photosynthesis. The bigger the cover, the bigger the engine, due to this fact trimming the vine’s cover may also help decrease its vigour, whereas protecting a bigger leaf space may also help encourage vigour. This must be thought of alongside airflow (to keep away from illness strain) and shading of the bunches (which may delay ripening). If the cover isn’t balanced with the amount of fruit, it could possibly additionally negatively impression fruit composition – particularly the acid make-up and growth of color and phenolics. Ivan Massonnat (Belargus) defined that in 2022 and 2023, for instance, he used a excessive trellis, permitting a bigger leaf space, to seize most mild and photosynthesis to gasoline the vines; however in 2022 he did the alternative, wanting to scale back the scale of the “sugar machine”. It has, he notes, develop into widespread for big canopies for use alongside low yields, particularly by producers in Burgundy, one thing he feels has gone too far at sure addresses: “You possibly can kill a wine with focus,” he says.

Some argue that trimming the cover can encourage it to develop additional, whereas others need to retain a big cover to encourage root development (Olivier Lamy feels that the vine has the identical quantity of development above and under floor, due to this fact eager to retain his cover to the roots to drive deep into the soil). Lamy is considered one of a cohort of producers utilizing “tressage”, or braiding, to tame the cover – a way pioneered by Lalou Bize-Leroy. For her the purpose is to keep away from reducing the apex (or rising tip) which might in any other case encourage the expansion of lateral shoots. Producers equivalent to Charles Lachaux have taken this even additional, coaching vines to a single stake (extra widespread on the steep slopes of Priorat, Côte-Rôtie or the Mosel) and weaving the shoots into distinctive arches.

*

The connection between yield and high quality is undoubtedly a difficult one – and one that each producer I spoke to feels is deeply complicated. We couldn’t contact on every part right here (the tiny yields for botrytised candy wines, for instance, or sometimes increased yields used for glowing wine), however there’s a lot to contemplate. Whereas it stays clear that extreme yields can produce dilute wines, with so many variables play, it’s additionally clear that much less isn’t at all times higher.

– Sophie Thorpe