A wine skilled’s foundational aim is to make others joyful. The restaurant sommelier goals to advocate a bottle that finest enhances a visitor’s eating expertise. The wine educator strives towards serving to their clientele decide the varieties and kinds they get pleasure from probably the most. The bottle store proprietor seeks to fulfill prospects by pointing them towards bottles that match an supposed temper and align with their sensibilities.
In every situation, success comes from the wine professional setting their very own preferences apart for the great of others. This noble gesture comes with a caveat: The wine they’re recommending could also be a label, selection, or fashion that they discover to be a bit overrated. They’ll nonetheless counsel the wine in the event that they consider it would please the shopper or visitor, however they could not essentially be thrilled with doing so.
With that in thoughts, we requested 12 wine professionals to call the wines they really feel take up an excessive amount of room on the hype practice. The wines they selected aren’t objectively dangerous, after all. They’re simply subjectively not for them.
Do not Miss A Drop
Get the newest in beer, wine, and cocktail tradition despatched straight to your inbox.
The Most Overrated Wines, In line with Wine Professionals:
- Pure wine
- Wines in heavy bottles
- Chillable reds
- Wines that overemphasize terroir
- New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc
- Large Cabernets and Cab blends as vacation items
- Sancerre
- Overtly funky pure wines
- Costly Pinot Grigio
- Napa wines
“There’s quite a lot of stiff competitors on the market, like massive model California Cabernet Sauvignons and limp, insipid Sancerre, however truthfully I feel pure wine has had its time and would profit from taking much less of a highlight. I’m all for emphasizing sustainable viticulture and letting fruit communicate for itself with readability and purity, however does each aspirational wine listing or stylish opening need to lean solely into ‘natty’ producers? Don’t get me incorrect, there are extremely gifted pure winemakers who create standout and differentiated expressions of each acquainted and novel grapes, however there’s an terrible lot of haphazardly made, overpriced, and admittedly tedious wines on the market that apparently we must be obsessed with.” —Gareth Rees, beverage director, Ilili, NYC
“Absurdly heavy wine bottles. They mainly act as free weights for somms, and so they largely carry mediocre plonk inside. They’re the Hummers of the wine world — all concerning the picture, however what’s beneath the hood is an engine that hardly strikes the needle. The memo must exit {that a} wine’s high quality isn’t proportional to how a lot it checks your grip power.” —Chris Schmid, accomplice/SVP strategic partnerships, Status Ledroit Distributing Co., Elkridge, Md.
“Chillable reds. I do know they’re having their second proper now, however I concern the market has turn into oversaturated with them.” —Jade Palmer, wine educator, The Oenophile Institute, Smyrna, Ga.
“Whereas terroir is a necessary side of winemaking, the romanticized notion that it solely defines a wine’s high quality can overshadow the winemaker’s talent and decisions. It’s necessary to acknowledge that each components contribute to the ultimate product.” —Grant Hewitt, vice chairman beverage, Loews Lodges & Co., NYC
“I’d say some of the overrated developments within the wine world is the obsession with pure wine as a blanket class. The time period itself has turn into so loosely outlined and overused that it typically prioritizes trendiness over high quality or transparency. And whereas I feel it’s nice to see how pure wine has introduced extra consideration to sustainable practices, the hype can typically overshadow unimaginable wines being made with equally considerate, low-intervention approaches that don’t essentially carry the ‘pure’ tag.” —Matt Bostic, sommelier/hospitality director, Llano Estacado Vineyard, Lubbock, Texas
“New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc is overrated. These wines of low-to-mediocre high quality are simply accessible, however typically style like candied grapefruit and may typically exhibit cat-pee-like aromas with a little bit of hay and grass. The flavors are so intense, it would fully take over any meals that might be loved with it when paired. It pays to have a look at smaller areas which can be actually making an attempt to craft a wine as a substitute — a Sauvignon Blanc from South America and even Greece may give far more bang in your buck. They’ve nice flavors which can be properly built-in and suited to being loved with meals.” —Autumn Gilliam, proprietor, The Adventurous Sip, Rochester, Minn.
“Overtly funky pure wines are overrated. There’s a spectrum of pure wines: Some style extra like kombucha, cider, or bitter beer, whereas others style extra squarely like wine. Sadly, evidently pure wines have become a ‘how a lot funk can one deal with?’ class.” —Brianne Cohen, wine educator, Brianne Cohen Wine & Occasions, Los Angeles
“I feel massive Cabs and Cab blends are overrated across the holidays, but they are usually what folks purchase for presents. I wish to remind those who lighter wines are nice suits for the season. Get your folks one thing they’ll get pleasure from with out meals! Large, classic Bordeaux have their place, after all, however I virtually by no means wish to drink them in the course of the vacation season. I really like a very good Trousseau or Gamay Noir as a substitute.” —Matt Robinson, founder, The Scout Wine Bar & Bottle Store, Gresham, Ore.
“If I may solely choose one, I’d say Sancerre. Folks order it with out actually giving a lot thought to what’s behind it. In fact, there are lovely Sancerre on the market, and I champion them typically. Nonetheless, as a result of intensely fragrant profile that’s largely of an industrial, packeted yeast-driven nature, the true essence of on a regular basis Sancerre is never revealed and the enduring or intrinsic producers are hardly ever discovered.” —Jill Mott, wine director, The Carlyle, a Rosewood Lodge, NYC
“I’d argue that pure wine is among the most overrated classes. That stated, I do have some caveats. There’s an inclination to imagine that if a wine is labeled as ‘pure,’ it needs to be funky and stuffed with what many winemakers would contemplate flaws — and people wines typically get overhyped. Nonetheless, as with most developments, the pendulum ultimately swings again towards steadiness.” —Michelle Morin, director of beverage, Waldorf Astoria Monarch Seashore Resort & Membership, Dana Level, Calif.
“Costly Pinot Grigio. ‘Cheap’ doesn’t inherently imply ‘dangerous.’ There are many examples of Pinot Grigio with good character at a cheaper price level. However too many individuals pay a premium for dangerous ones with sturdy model recognition. and it makes me a bit unhappy.” —Chris Struck, Wine Educator, NYC
“Probably the most overrated wines could be these from Napa Valley. Now, Napa Valley can produce some scrumptious wines, however oftentimes you’re paying extra for the identify and fewer for the standard of the wine. I’ve tasted loads of Napa Valley wines as a beverage director, and I’ve by no means tasted one the place I couldn’t discover a related wine of equal or greater high quality for half the value. If somebody is lifeless set on a California wine, I all the time push folks extra in direction of the [state’s] Paso Robles area. You will get phenomenal wines in high quality and flavors for a lot lower than a Napa Valley wine.” —Tyler Flynn, beverage director, EsterEv, Milwaukee
*Picture retrieved from Andrii Zastrozhnov – inventory.adobe.com
