Properly of us, it lastly occurred. In 2024, the variety of craft breweries that closed was larger than the variety of people who opened.
With respect to all of the breweries that went out of enterprise final 12 months: That is superb. This needed to occur. Frankly, it ought to’ve occurred already. The bubble hasn’t burst, craft beer isn’t useless. The American craft brewing business’s closure charge was an ahistorical monkey on its again, and now it’s gone. I’d even enterprise as far as to say it’s most likely for the perfect.
Earlier this week, The New York Instances revealed a report pegged to the opening/closing flip-flop by longtime beer journalist and VinePair contributor Josh M. Bernstein titled “Has the Craft Beer Trade’s Keg Lastly Kicked?” For those who, like me, have been repeatedly despatched this text by normie family and friends questioning whether or not the jig was certainly up on full-flavored beer, I encourage you to take a second to reply with a hyperlink to the Wikipedia entry for Betteridge’s legislation of headlines. For the uninitiated, it goes as follows: “Any headline that ends in a query mark might be answered by the phrase no.”
Do not Miss A Drop
Get the newest in beer, wine, and cocktail tradition despatched straight to your inbox.
“Has the craft beer business’s keg lastly kicked?” wonders the Grey Woman above Bernstein’s in any other case strong procedural on the section.
“No,” responds Ian Betteridge. Your humble Hop Take columnist concurs.
This isn’t to say 2024 was 12 months for craft brewers. Removed from it. As soon as the mud settles and the info are tabulated, the section will possible end out 2024 with manufacturing volumes down 2–3 %, based on a mid-December projection from the Brewers Affiliation (BA). Distributors and retailers shifted focus to imports, flavored malt drinks, and non-alcoholic choices. Draft, the channel through which craft brewers have overindexed for many years, nonetheless struggled. Massive honkin’ juice bombs within the Voodoo Ranger mode should not the panacea they as soon as appeared to be, and the craft brewers that attempted to seek out “their take” on exhausting seltzer principally acquired taken for a journey. The mergers-and-acquisitions bonanza of final decade reached its logical conclusion in 2024, with each main macrobrewer within the nation shedding some or all of their craft brewing portfolios. Barely anyone was shopping for craft breweries moreover Tilray Manufacturers or different craft breweries, and whereas the previous’s chief govt claims to have a method to revive the section writ massive, the latter are principally hunkering right down to climate the “second shakeout.”
They’re the fortunate ones. The BA’s 2024 12 months in Beer recap, revealed Dec. 10, cited 399 breweries closed final 12 months, in comparison with simply 335 openings. “Craft has been going by way of a painful interval of rationalization,” incoming president and chief govt Bart Watson mentioned in an announcement. In feedback in a webinar on the year-end supplies reported by Brewbound, he famous that the section’s closure charge, whereas now within the crimson for the primary time since 2005, is “nonetheless low” in comparison with the hospitality sector at massive. However it is going to possible get extra painful from right here: Watson anticipates the development to proceed into 2025.
I really feel for the brewers that went bust final 12 months. A few of them did all the things proper and nonetheless went incorrect. Others didn’t do all the things proper, however would’ve loved loads of respiration room to determine it out in the event that they’d solely opened final decade, when the tailwinds have been robust and the BA was envisioning craft beer making up 20 % of the general share of U.S. beer gross sales by 2020. “We had a plan and a backup plan and one other backup plan,” the proprietor of Steam Bell Brewery in Chesterfield, Va., advised the Richmond Instances-Dispatch in August, describing why the brewery was closing after eight years in enterprise. “All of them slowly fell by way of.” What number of variations of that story did you encounter final 12 months in heartfelt social media posts or over farewell pints in too-empty taprooms? I misplaced depend, reader. It’s a bummer, no two methods about it.
Right here’s the factor to recollect as you zoom out on the person brewery closures and attempt to decipher what it means for the business that continues to be. The craft brewing growth that began within the late aughts and continued by way of most of final decade was by no means going to final. The nation went from round 1,500 breweries in 2010 to round 9,500 in 2020, an astonishing uptick nicely north of 500 %. You understand how typically after I’m writing a couple of scorching new product posting astronomical year-over-year gross sales development, I be aware that these features must be taken with a grain of salt as a result of they’re approaching a small base? The identical fundamental caveat applies when pondering the trajectory of the craft brewing section. Sure, the variety of craft breweries grew like gangbusters for a decade, stoked on by real drinker curiosity and low-interest loans. Then it flattened out, as a result of there have been fewer and fewer locations within the nation that may be capable to maintain breweries that didn’t have already got one (or a number of). In 2024, it has ever so barely decreased, and it most likely will in 2025, too. So it goes in once-hot industries: they finally cool off.
That is chilly consolation for the homeowners and employees whose breweries went bust, and the drinkers who hung out (and hopefully cash, albeit not sufficient within the mixture) establishing their taprooms as group hubs, tabletop gaming locations, and so forth. However there are three silver linings to this contraction for the craft breweries which are nonetheless in enterprise.
The primary is that there are bargains aplenty for these operators in place to take benefit. When Orpheus Brewing closed in Atlanta in 2023, Good Beer Searching (now itself defunct, sadly) reported the brewery offered its canning line and depalletizer for lower than than a tenth of what it’d paid for them new. “You’re going to finish up with so much [of equipment] that doesn’t promote and simply will get scrapped, as a result of there’s simply a lot extra capability,” predicted founder and brewmaster Jason Pellet in June of that 12 months. Some 18 months later, Bernstein tells the opposite facet of this story, reporting how Tennessee’s TailGate Brewing, with a whip hand on the proper time, has scooped up an $80,000 grain silo for $500 and a $750,000 centrifuge for $50,000. “It’s a purchaser’s market,” one other brewer advised the Instances. Certainly.
The second is that the craft beer market has been a chaotic, complicated hodgepodge for some time now. A variety of craft breweries have been taking over house on cabinets and faucet towers with mediocre beer, turning off shoppers, overwhelming retailers, and annoying the shit out of distributors. In August 2024, Left Hand Brewing’s co-founder Eric Wallace outlined his plan to construct a craft-brewing platform to provide beer and different drinks extra effectively than present corporations might do solo. He was cautious to emphasize to Brewbound that Left Hand wished to accomplice with manufacturers “assuming that [they have] a cause to be available in the market.” Wallace is aware of from what he speaks, having weathered craft brewing’s first shakeout within the late ‘90s and early aughts. Among the breweries that closed this 12 months didn’t have a cause to be available in the market, and merely weren’t constructed for it.
The ultimate cause I feel the BA’s newest closure numbers aren’t any dying knell for the American craft brewing business is extra summary. Observe me right here. In 2018, proper because the section’s distinctive heater was beginning to peter out, The Atlantic revealed a narrative calling craft beer “the strangest, happiest financial story in America.” It codified for a mainstream readership a lot of the self-mythologizing that first- and second-wave craft brewers had executed concerning the enterprise: that theirs was a David-and-Goliath battle in opposition to Massive Beer; that the three-tier system, odious as it might be to a few of its contributors, had created a rare alternative for small, unbiased breweries to thrive; that the Nice Recession created a cohort of “necessity entrepreneurs” who might unlock worth that larger corporations couldn’t. All of those claims — and extra quippy insider slogans like “a rising tide lifts all boats,” and “craft beer is 99 % asshole-free” — had kernels of fact to them, in fact. However collectively, they evoke an business that has traded on exceptionalism with its clients, and itself.
Craft beer is great, nevertheless it’s not distinctive. It’s topic to the identical forces that form the remainder of our financial system, like company union busting, sexual harassment, and pure disasters. For a lot of final decade, it appeared just like the section had exempted itself from the downward stress of commodity and the capriciousness of shopper tastes. For those who wished to be satisfied that craft brewing would at all times continue to grow — that brewery openings would at all times outpace closures, till such time that there was a brewery on each nook of the nation — there have been loads of individuals on the market able to persuade you, typically proper earlier than asking you to signal a lease or minimize a verify. However the line couldn’t go up eternally, and it hasn’t.
I don’t count on the craft brewing business to magically rebound this 12 months simply because the closure charge lastly flip-flopped. I do count on the brewers that stay to be that rather more critical to remain on the suitable facet of it, and better of luck to them. The mirage of an distinctive craft brewing business is useless, and craft brewing remains to be alive. That silver lining shines fairly darn shiny to me.
🤯 Hop-ocalypse Now
For many years, Boston Beer Firm’s co-founder and chairman Jim Koch preferred to inform those that his succession plan was “don’t die.” The morbid humor hits completely different now that the elder statesman of American craft brewing is 75 years previous. Lo: On Christmas Day, The Wall Avenue Journal revealed just a little Samuel Adams scoop noting that within the occasion of his dying, Koch now plans to go off his Class B shares — and with them, de facto management of the publicly traded agency — to his spouse, well being care entrepreneur Cynthia Fisher. (She’s 63, and a board member at BBC.) Instances, they’re a-changin’.
📈 Ups…
Beer, not Champagne, is the drink People deliberate to buy most for New 12 months’s Eve, in accordance to a late December survey from Numerator… Mass Bay Brewing Co. and Finestkind Brewing have merged into the Barrel One Collective, a 14-brand New England craft roll-up..
📉 …and downs
The Nationwide Beer Wholesalers Affiliation’s ultimate Beer Purchasers’ Index of the 12 months was an enchancment over the prior three months, however nonetheless beneath its 10-year common… Non-public management of the U.S. hop crop ticked upward to 63 % in 2024, per the just-dropped USDA Hop Report…
This story is part of VP Professional, our free platform and publication for drinks business professionals, protecting wine, beer, liquor, and past. Join VP Professional now!
